Saturday, February 15, 2020

Hospitalization and Frailty

Maureen in the afternoon sun

Aside from the two times she gave birth, my mother has never had to stay in a hospital. She has had cataract surgery, Mohs surgery for skin cancers, and she has been treated in an emergency room and in an urgent care facility, but as of this week, she has never been hospitalized overnight for illness. Now that she has Alzheimer’s, I have dreaded the possibility of having to either call an ambulance, or admit her to a hospital, as I feared the resulting anxiety and disorientation would be more debilitating than whatever affliction might befall her. So last weekend when she began to have serious rectal bleeding, I made a round of phone calls and found that my anesthesia doctor from my recent ankle surgery was also practicing geriatric medicine and could do a house call that same afternoon. Imagine that! 

He immediately had me suspend four of her medications. Two were her Alzheimer’s medications, donepezil and memantine, here in Italy known as Aricept and Ebixa. For some time I had suspected they were doing more damage than good. In fact I recently read that memantine and donepezil should not be taken together, and not by patients with heart conditions. My mother has both high blood pressure and a heart arrhythmia. Donepezil is also bad for people with asthma, which my mother has had all her life. The other drug was warfarin, which thins the blood to presumably prevent strokes and heart attacks, but it carries a risky potential for causing internal bleeding. We agreed that hospitalization was not yet necessary, and might make matters worse for her. When her symptoms persisted the next day, he had her admitted to a private hospital not far from where we live.

Her hemoglobin was dangerously low, so she was given blood and plasma transfusions in order to prepare her for a diagnostic endoscopy and colonoscopy the following day. Thankfully with the help of some fantastic nurses, I got her through the prep and we had generally good news from the procedures: no tumors, no hemorrhoids, no need for any surgery. However, she had diverticulitis, and the working hypothesis was that her worsening anemia coupled with the impact of that cocktail of medications caused internal bleeding that eventually led to the hemorrhaging. Luckily a careful diet can help the intestinal healing, and now we will work to figure out how to improve her heart and lung health. 

I imagine readers of this blog are well aware of the dubious results of these two widely prescribed Alzheimer’s medications, and of the many undesirable side effects. Dr. Dale Bredesen whose work I have previously written about, posted on his Facebook page about a year ago about a meta analysis:
a recent study showed that patients treated with standard Alzheimer’s drugs donepezil (Aricept) or memantine (Namenda) actually declined more rapidly than those who were not treated with those drugs (Kennedy et al., JAMA Network Open. 2018;1(7):e184080. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2018.4080

What may be less understood by caretakers and even medical professionals is how the frailty of old age can mean unseen vulnerability that is not diagnosed with typical bloodwork and routine doctor visits. I think of myself as a pretty well-informed caretaker, someone who has done a lot of reading about Alzheimer’s, but I did not go to medical school, so I put a great deal of trust in doctors. When I saw symptoms like nighttime coughing, complaints of feeling cold, rising creatinine levels, increased sleepiness, breathlessness with fatigue, I did not pursue the possible reasons, even though I wondered about the medicines that negatively impacted kidney function. My mother’s doctor most recently diagnosed a flair up of asthma and prescribed prednisone, and it reassured me the chest x-ray showed no change from the previous one and therefore she felt the heart was not to blame for her symptoms. In retrospect, I am shocked that a simple online search turned up the fact that iron-deficiency anemia (which my mother has been taking iron supplements for since late fall) is almost always due to blood loss, and a simple test can determine if there is blood in the stomach or bowels. 

Lessons learned the hard way always leave a residue of guilt. I am grateful for the happy outcome of the procedure, for a trustworthy and competent doctor and his colleagues at the hospital, and for a mother who is a stubborn warrior and even in her most distressed state was willing to fight through it. I am more skeptical than before all this happened about the medical establishment, which seems even more dysfunctional than the really messed up field of education that has been my life's work. I see disturbing parallels. We know from replicable and reliable research that these medications are not working and are even dangerous, yet millions continue to take them in the hope they'll do something for their loved ones. We know that the toxic testing culture taking over educational settings is not improving learning outcomes and is actually harmful to students and teachers, yet we persist in ranking, sorting, praising and publicly humiliating people. We have a long way to go. We're not getting younger, and most of us are not getting healthier. Or for that matter, smarter. 

1 comment:

  1. interesting read thank you Alexandra …. I love that you have a stubborn warrior mum - sounds like she learned some life skills that she still harnesses

    ReplyDelete